Monday December 11, 2017
Home Opinion AAP-BJP confl...

AAP-BJP conflict: How Delhi’s current situation is a reminder of the 1960s political scenario of Bengal

5
391
New Delhi: Lieutenant Governor Najeeb Jung before administrating the oath of office and secrecy to Arvind Kejriwal as the Delhi Chief Minister at Ramlila maidan in New Delhi on Saturday. PTI Photo by Shahbaz Khan(PTI12_28_2013_000077B)

INDIA-POLITICS-CORRUPTION-LAW-PARLIAMENT

By Dr. Kallol Guha

In reference to the conflict between Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) led Delhi government and the Central government, it may be relevant to recall the fate of the first non-Congress government of Kerala back in 1957. Chief Minister Namboodripad’s CPI government had introduced a Bill for reforms in land and education that threatened the power of local landowners and their allies (Nair Service Society),  including the Christian churches.

Statewide agitation against the government continued under the leadership of the Indian National Congress, which was at the Centre. The landlord community (Nair Service Society), church groups along with several other opposition parties, with the support of Central Intelligence Agency, as claimed by CPI, joined the agitation. This led to President’s rule in the state as the state government of CPI was dismissed under the pretext of law and order in July 1959.

A similar incident occurred in 1967 in West Bengal when the first non-Congress government under the leadership of United Left Front (ULF) was formed. They tried to introduce marginal reforms in favor of workers, peasants and lower middle class. Propertied class felt threatened, mainstream media turned their ‘marketing tools’ on to discredit the ULF. Congress, which was in power at the centre, organized agitation against the ULF on various issues. One fine morning, the state government was dismissed and governor’s rule was introduced. ULF then returned to power, compromising with the classes they ostensibly opposed and picked on the leftovers until booted out by All India Trinamool Congress (TMC).

Aam Aadmi Vs Ruling Class

Let us try to understand, in the above context, the genesis of the quarrel between the AAP government in Delhi and the BJP government at the Centre. There are different types of government across the world which are identified with various nomenclature. For instance, military dictatorship in Burma, monarchy in Saudi Arabia, socialist like North Vietnam and North Korea among others. Anglophonic countries are identified as democratic simply because people have voting rights to elect a government.

The real administrative power on issues such as land and industry, judiciary and executive, police and army, mainstream media still remains under the control of land-owners and well-known industrialists. This class, in left political circle, is branded as ‘Ruling Class’. In straight words, the administration of a given country always functions to protect the interest of this ruling class. This basic principle must be kept in mind to understand the conflict between the Delhi state government and the Central government.

AAP, at this point of time, seems to be committed to curb corruption by all means at their disposal. Whatever corruption they might have curbed by now, it has invariably threatened the interest of the ruling class in several ways. The ruling class might have lost significant income from illicit sources. If corruption is allowed to be curbed, this trend will invariably increase not just in Delhi but throughout the nation which will be a political suicide for the ruling class. The mask of democracy, prosperity and development might be torn from the face of the ruling parties if AAP is allowed to function undisturbed. The mainstream media whose role is to make people believe, through the modern marketing tools, that the ruling party will make common man’s life better is threatened that people might discover that the brand of  democracy is in fact, an exercise of a flock of sheep choosing their own butcher.

Freedom of Press or Propaganda 

BJP Government will continue to use their tools, notably the Lieutenant Governor and bureaucracy, to make sure that AAP is unable to function well enough to deliver services to the masses. The mainstream media will then use their ‘freedom of press’ and ‘freedom of expression’ to showcase AAP’s inefficiency to govern and hence  portray BJP as the one who can deliver the services.

Here people’s verdict does not matter. Democracy does not matter. Quality of people’s  lives does not matter. National development does not matter. The only thing that matters is material gain of the ruling class and the power and influence required to safeguard that gain.

Prosperity of India, if any, is definitely not due to the government. This prosperity, however marginal, is solely a product of Indian people’s brilliance, stamina and entrepreneurship. Those who were in power during the last 65 years, though reduced to their minimum existence in political terms, are not only untouched by the mainstream media but there is a distinct plot by the media to gradually drag them into the limelight.

Therefore, it is understandable why the mainstream media, most of it foreign owned, is using all their marketing tools to brand AAP as the ‘devil’ and it will not be otherwise as long as AAP holds on to their pro-people agenda.  On Wednesday, Karan Thapar on CNN-IBN conducted a debate on whether the relation between Central and the Delhi government is heading towards dismissal of AAP Government under the pretext of violation of Constitution.

It is pertinent to recall the Left-Wing doctrine. They declared that propertied ruling class will never ever relinquish power on their own. They will put up with ‘democracy’ and ‘free election’ as long as it does not threaten their control over wealth of the nation. In the past, government elected by the people has been dissolved under some pretext or replaced by military intervention, when they tried to implement policies in favor of common people. Last century, it happened in almost every country in South America, Brazil, Congo, Iran, Cuba, Vietnam and Korea.  Now history is repeating itself in Delhi.

What can AAP do under the present circumstances? One possibility is that they pay lip service to ideas of improving quality of life for the common people but in fact compromise with the culture of ruling class which is characterized by corruption, chaos and chronic under-development. Other possibility is to mobilize general population by convincing them about the real nature of the rat trap they are stuck in under the illusion of ‘democracy’ and ‘free election’ and prepare them to take a stand in favor of their own destiny.

  • Neeru Bahl

    Many thanks Dr Guha for explaining so nicely, why BJP-Combo wants AAPGovt dysfunctional. After reading this piece even BJP supporters would be forced to analyse BJP-Cong hidden agenda.

  • Just Faking

    Wonderful gem…i read many article but hardly come across such brilliiant stuff… for a moment i thought orwell is back….enough said!

  • Kallol Guha Phd

    Delhi was once invaded by Taimur, Nadir Shah, Ahmed Abdali, British during first war of independence in 1857. Those invaders appeared and disappeared like lightning. Now there are new species of invaders who are here to stay- who jabber “FREEDOM OF PRESS” and “FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION” wear the mask of “WORLD’S LARGEST DEMOCRACY” when it suits them. But show no respect for people’s mandate when it goes against their selfish interest.

  • kirti Kumar pal

    AAP govt. indeed have difficult choice. Only viable and wise alternative left for them is to make constant contact with public and make them aware of evil design of ruling elites. ultimately against all odds and knowing pitfalls in electing AAO ,it is people of Delhi who made them victorious ,thrashing hopes of various vested interests.

  • programmer

    I agree that AAP has intentions to remove the corrptions, however I doubt if they will be successful. Corruption is in our DNA. We have huge population with limited resources. So there will always be competition for getting hold of resources by any means.

  • Neeru Bahl

    Many thanks Dr Guha for explaining so nicely, why BJP-Combo wants AAPGovt dysfunctional. After reading this piece even BJP supporters would be forced to analyse BJP-Cong hidden agenda.

  • Just Faking

    Wonderful gem…i read many article but hardly come across such brilliiant stuff… for a moment i thought orwell is back….enough said!

  • Kallol Guha Phd

    Delhi was once invaded by Taimur, Nadir Shah, Ahmed Abdali, British during first war of independence in 1857. Those invaders appeared and disappeared like lightning. Now there are new species of invaders who are here to stay- who jabber “FREEDOM OF PRESS” and “FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION” wear the mask of “WORLD’S LARGEST DEMOCRACY” when it suits them. But show no respect for people’s mandate when it goes against their selfish interest.

  • kirti Kumar pal

    AAP govt. indeed have difficult choice. Only viable and wise alternative left for them is to make constant contact with public and make them aware of evil design of ruling elites. ultimately against all odds and knowing pitfalls in electing AAO ,it is people of Delhi who made them victorious ,thrashing hopes of various vested interests.

  • programmer

    I agree that AAP has intentions to remove the corrptions, however I doubt if they will be successful. Corruption is in our DNA. We have huge population with limited resources. So there will always be competition for getting hold of resources by any means.

Next Story

Forks in the Road : 10 places to eat in Delhi

Delhi has so many diverse cuisines to offer. Here is the list of 10 places to eat in delhi which you can not miss

0
12
Foodie Delhi
10 places to eat in Delhi (pexels)

Delhi, the present day cultural hub of India, which was once under the rule of The Parthians, The Turks, The Afghans, The Mughals and The Britishers which left an impact on the city and gave it its own  unique status. Tourists from all over the world come down to Delhi and lose their hearts to it scrumptious cuisines.

It’s winter in Delhi, a perfect weather for sampling Delhi’s most famous attractions- its incredible street food. It’s not just the street food that Delhi is famous for but a lot of history and culture that is mixed up with the food. Everything from Asoka era to Mughals to the invaders who held sway over Delhi to Purana Qila, have left the taste of the food behind.

To the variety of chats that will take you on tour of tangy, sweet and spicy flavours to the non-vegetarian food which will remind of the rich flavours to the food never tasted anywhere, Delhi has it all.

Here are 10 places to visit for indulging into the flavors of Delhi.

  1. Paranthe Wali Gali
IndianGyaan

 

Paranthe Wali Gali since 1870s is the name of a narrow street in the Chandni Chowk area of Delhi known for its series of shops selling parantha, an Indian flatbread. The food is old fashioned, strictly vegetarian and the cooked dishes do not include onion or garlic. Stuffed aloo (potato), Gobi (cauliflower) and matar (peas) paranthas are the most popular ones. Lentil paranthas are also available. The cost could come up to 150 rupees for 2 people. This street is lit from 9 a.m. to 11 p.m.

  1. Dilli Haat
India Opines

Dilli Haat does not only showcase the rich Indian culture and diverse Indian Heritage, but is also one of the best place to enjoy regional food from all over the country. Dilli Haat provides various food stalls having food from various Indian States that gives you a variety of choice at low cost prices. Its timings are from 10:30 a.m. to 10:30 p.m. Bijoli Grill- a West Bengal food stall offering Fish curry and Kosha Mangsho; Momo Mia, an Arunanchal Pradesh food stall offering Momos and Fruit Beer; Nagaland Kitchen, a Nagaland food stall offering Raja Mircha and Momos; Manipur Foods, a Manipuri Food Stall offering Fried Rice, Tarai Tong ad Fruit Beer; Rajasthani Food Stall offering Pyaaz Kachori, Desi Ghee Jalebi and Rajasthani Thali; Maharashtra Food Stall offering Vada Pav, Puran Poli, Shrikhand; Dawath-E-Awadh, a UP Food Stall offering Kebabs, Biryani and Phirni and other food stalls from states such as Andhra Pradesh, Assam and Kerala.

  1. Khan Market
The Urban Escapades

Khan Market is not only a place for die hard shoppers, it is also Delhi’s incredible food districts. A neighborhood that never sleeps, whose streets are filled with the scent of mutton kebab and fried rice. Khan Market has restaurants such as Town Hall Restaurant, The Big Chili Café, Yellow Brick Road Restaurant, Wok in Clouds, The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf, Soda bottle opner wala, Azam’s Mughlai, Café Turtle, Omazoni and Market Café.

  1. Spice Aangan
EazyDiner

Tucked away in Safdarjung Development Area’s main market is a hole-in-the-wall tandoor-and-takeaway restaurant known as Spice Aangan. Spice Aangan has been a staple of the SDA market food scene for a while now. The hole-in-the-wall is bang opposite the small, grassless park located at the centre of the market. While there are a couple of steel benches at edge of the park to sit and enjoy their food, it is otherwise a purely takeaway and home delivery outlet. Restaurant serves tandoori snacks–chicken tikka, malai tikka, seekh kebab–as well as mutton dishes, curries, biryani and shawarma rolls. Despite so many options, though, you’d be hard pressed to find the regulars ordering anything other than the chicken shawarma.

  1. Karim’s
Musafir

Karim’s is a historic restaurant located near Jama Masjid Gali Kababian, Old Delhi, Delhi. It is know that this is the best restaurant in Delhi, serving non-vegetarian food since 1913. The original Karim’s is bang opposite Jama Masjid in the walled city area of Delhi. It is close to a market known as Darya Ganj. Those visiting Karim’s for the first time will be surprised at the location. Getting there is not easy, you will need to ask locals for help. Mutton Burra, Mutton Raan-this starter is huge, and is meant for four or five people. There is a wide range of kebabs including Seekh Kebabs, Shammi Kebabs and Mutton Tikka. Chicken Seekh Kebab, Tandoori Chicken or Chicken Tikka for those who love chicken. Mutton Korma, Mutton Stew and Badam Pasanda Chicken Noor Jehan and Chicken Jahangiri are the main courses to be tried once you get there. As for the bread Khamiri Roti is something not to be missed. Karim’s serves two main desserts Kheer Benazir and Shahi Tukda.

  1. Pandara Road
ScoopWhoop

Delhi serves delectable food in almost every nook and corner of the city. Whether it is crowded streets of Chandni Chowk or the sophisticated eateries of Khan Market. One such stop is Pandara Road Market, located near India Gate, the place serves best non-vegetarian food of the city, so all the meat lovers out there fill your wallets. Havemore offering the best Butter chicken and garlic naan and Gulati which is best known for its Dum Biryani and kebabs with the cost price of 1500 rupees for two, and many other restaurants like Chicken Inn, Pindi and Ichiban.

  1. Amar Colony
TripAdvisor

Amar Colony is generally known to be the hub of garments but it is also the hidden street food hub. Home to a diverse population from India, Africa and Afghanistan, there is no doubt, diversity in food here too. A number of small joints for street food in Amar Colony exist which serve the most delicious dishes for you. Most of the shops are situated in the main market and are close to each other. Nagpal Chole Bhature, Hunger Strike, Tibb’s Frankie, Biryani Corner, 34 Chowringhee Lane, Sharma Chaat Bhandar, Deepaul’s Café, Dolma Aunty Momos, Muttu South Indian Anna, High On Burger are the best places to visit when on Pandara Road.

Follow NewsGram at Facebook : NewsGram.Com

  1. Hudson Lane, GTB Nagar
MY APRON DIARIES – WordPress.com

Hudson Lane, very close to the main North Campus area, is one place where you will find one of the finest cafés and best restaurants in Delhi. Mostly serving Italian, Café, and Fast Food Cuisine, these quirky joints offer an amazing culinary experience at an extremely pocket-friendly price. Woodbox Café, Mad Monkey, Indus Flavors, QD’s, Ricos and Big yellow Door are the most recommended places to munch at.

  1. Jung Bahadur Kachori Wala
Delhipedia

Situated near Paranthe Wali Gal, Jung Bahadur Kachori Wala is a small but popular street stall that’s been serving sought- after Kachoris since the early 1970s. Kachori stuffed with urad dal and served with special spicy chutney is a must try ther.

  1. Connaught Place
India Today – India Today Group

From fancy revolving restaurants to the delicious local rajma chawal, Connaught place does not discriminate when it comes to food. Home to some of the best restaurants in Delhii and also ironic dahbas, one can relish all kinds of cuisines here be it local, regional or international. Kake Da Hotel, Parikrama, Jain Chawal Wale, Minar and much more are the places to step up with.

Next Story

Narendra Modi App : Amazing Platform where Prime Minister connects with the citizens

Wanna give ideas to or interact with Prime Minister Narendra Modi? Go and download Narendra Modi app on android and iOs

0
60
Narendra Modi App
Prime Minister Narendra Modi (FILE PHOTO)

Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi has an amazing sense of connecting with masses. Prime Minister knows the nerve of Indian public and at various instances proves himself as a pan Indian leader. Prime Minster Modi is undoubtedly one of the most tech-savvy global leader and a big promoter of e-governance and m-governance since a long time. Within two months of assuming Prime Minister-ship, he had launched the ambitious myGov project. In continuing the tradition of citizen connect, Prime Minister Modi took another step towards connecting with the people at their convenience by launching Narendra Modi app couple of years back.

Narendra Modi app
Prime Minister launching Narendra Modi App

The Narendra Modi app provides updates on the day-to-day activities of Prime Minister Narendra Modi. It presents an opportunity to receive messages and emails directly from Shri Narendra Modi. There is also an option to contribute and earn ‘badges’ through to-do tasks in various social initiatives. Through Narendra Modi app, one can tune-in and listen to the various episodes of ‘Mann ki Baat’, read Prime Minister Modi’s blogs, and get to know more about him from his Biography section. Narendra Modi app also provides comprehensive information on initiatives and achievements of the Union Government, which has an ‘infographics’ section for insights.

Such type of initiative by a global leader gives a strong message how technology can be used by governments to bridge gap between leaders and citizens. apart from this app Prime Minister Modi is also very much active on various social media platforms such as Facebook, Twitter, Instagram etc. Prime Minister Modi is the one of the most followed global leader on Twitter.

So what are you waiting for. Go and share some ideas of innovation with Prime Minister Narendra Modi and contribute in his vision of “Sabka Sath, Sabka Vikas”.

– by SHAURYA RITWIK, Shaurya is Sub-Editor at NewsGram and writes on Geo-politcs, Culture, Indology and Business. Twitter Handle – @shauryaritwik

Next Story

Stand of Chanda Bandh Satyagraha: Hamari AAP ka Siyasi Dafan poora ho, Hamara Hawan Poora Ho

A true volunteer of AAP will not rest until a morally debased AAP is not consigned to flames.

0
41
Chanda Bandh Satyagraha appeals to AAP leaders to make donations public.
Chanda Bandh Satyagraha appeals to AAP leaders to make donations public.
  • By Dr. Munish Raizada

One of our steadfast volunteers sent me a message at Facebook and sought my opinion on the current dogfight going between #ChandaChor gang of our Aam Aadmi Party (AAP).

Through Chanda Bandh Satyagraha, our stand is clearly a matter of conviction:

सच्चे स्वयंसेवक का यज्ञ तभी पूरा होगा , जब सिधान्तों से भटकी हमारी AAP की पूर्ण आहुति दे दी जाएगी.
अगर जनता का दिया गया चंदा खाओगे, तो कोई हक़ नहीं राजनीती में तुम्हे!
2020 में AAP का अंतकाल आना चाहिए. हमारी पार्टी का सियासी दफ़न पूरा हो, हमारा हवन पूरा हो.

Loosely translated: A true volunteer of AAP will not rest until a morally debased AAP is consigned to flames. Because a party that can eat away the public funds (donations), has no moral right to be in politics. The year 2020 will hopefully see the political demise of our AAP.

As you see the dogfight has come to the streets now. A poet is trying to revive and talking of an AAP II. Some well meaning volunteers are standing with him. He is zestfully speaking about bringing back values of the party and old folks too.

Tragically, the other Chandachor camp led by Mukhiya Kejriwal has termed this as a fantasy.

But, we must be able to read through the lines.

In my opinion, our hardcore selfless volunteers who really wanted to see a change of politics and polity through a vehicle called AAP, now understand that the fight is for personal survival and NOT for principles.

Chanda Bandh Satyagraha appeals to AAP leaders to make donations public.
Chanda Bandh Satyagraha appeals to AAP leaders to make donations public.

But the poet is fighting for his survival, so believe me, this fight will not lead him anywhere. It is NOT a MORAL fight. It is a personal fight. Janta ka vishwas nahi milega (public’s trust can not be regained). Janta ek Kejriwal ko dekh chuki hai (the public has already seen one Kejriwal). Abhi 20-30 saal wait kariye (Wait for another generation before you utter of revolution again).  Kraanti kee baaten kar ke janta ko aur dukhi mat kijiye (Do not exploit the sentiments of the society by talking about yet another revolution when the first one was never ever attained).

If you really care about the principles, just do one thing: Ask where is the donation list that the party received?  After all. how can a party fight against corruption and graft, if its own house is  not clean. And then talk about other principles.

Bringing back old folks is a good idea. Reviving AAP is a welcome idea. But, let us remember one thing: Public (janta) is not a toy. You can play with their sentiments once, not again and again.

At AAP, our refrain used to be:

सत्य परेशान हो सकता है, पराजित नहीं.

Today, we know in our hearts, we have eaten the donations given by the public. सत्य को चंदाचोरों व् ‘सत्यवीरों” ने परेशान भी किया तथा पराजित भी (Truth was not only messed around with, it was badly defeated by the so called saints of truth and honesty).

Then, what ideological principles is the poet talking about!

The dogfight is a fight without morality. It is a sign that the rot in our AAP is deep set. However, the karma cycle is trying to complete the circle. The dogfight is exposing the unworthiness of our AAP’s leaders who one time the public thought are statesmen. The poet is helping us achieve our cherished goal: Taking us towards the the Aahuti!