Never miss a story

Get subscribed to our newsletter

The demarcation between control and capital is one that can unleash the next phase of entrepreneurial activity in this country. Pixabay

The recent decision by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA) to amend the Companies Act and raise the cap on differential voting rights (DVRs) to 74 per cent has ramifications much beyond just the technology industry in India. The demarcation between control and capital is one that can unleash the next phase of entrepreneurial activity in this country.

The impact of the changes in DVRs is much beyond just businesses termed as “tech-businesses”. The changes allow a variety of entrepreneurs to benefit by accessing capital that can help boost businesses. While tech-businesses in capital intensive sectors will get a boost, so will entrepreneurs in other industries ranging from industrials to pharmaceutical research. The critical component is that the new regulation will allow an entrepreneur to marry their operational and entrepreneurial skills with the capital of a large investor, without necessarily having to part with significant control.

Additionally, entrepreneurs with substantial capacity to generate value through aggregating businesses in fragmented industries through a platform structure will also be able to utilise the higher cap on DVRs to create platforms that can generate value for all. Such platforms are applicable across sectors, where financial and operational inefficiencies exist.

The new rules regarding DVRs attempt at resolving the excessive debt dependence that Indian businesses have been vulnerable to, in the past, especially the reliance on bank loans. Reliance on bank loans was in part driven by a nascent corporate bond market and related factors that made bank loans a more attractive proposition for credit and in some cases, perhaps the only available option. On the other hand, the excessive dependence on debt by Indian companies was also driven by the need to avoid dilution of control that is a necessary concomitant of equity-based funding.

The recent decision by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA) to amend the Companies Act and raise the cap on differential voting rights (DVRs) to 74 per cent has ramifications much beyond just the technology industry in India. Pixabay

DVRs will allow firms to create more efficient capital structures by avoiding excessive leverage, a strategy wrongly used to prevent equity dilution in the past. The new DVR rules should be implemented for both private and publicly listed companies, to help shore up the capital structure regime in India. Critics of DVRs have pointed out that there are corporate governance issues concerning DVRs, whereby superior voting rights may lead to lower compliance standards. It is essential to differentiate between the various implications of a policy. The aim must be to improve corporate governance standards across the spectrum, but the benefits of DVRs in terms of allowing flexibility for entrepreneurs to push for capital, while still driving the company forward must not be underestimated.

Essentially, to state the obvious, the market must price an asset for the value delivered. In layman terms, if a shareholder with a share that has lesser control versus the shares held by a founder, then the shareholder needs to demand a higher return. Correct pricing of an asset relative to its risk is an issue that is applicable across asset classes. The question the investors must ask is how will the entrepreneur or the business compensate us for the fact that we own a share that has lesser voting rights? The question regulators must ask is how do we ensure that the regime and regulations that allow businesses to compensate shareholders with lesser rights are implemented effectively? DVRs can deliver value when the different stakeholders ask the right questions. Efficient financial markets will ensure that the stakeholders can all generate the maximum value for themselves.

In an Indian context, DVR rules are especially crucial for privately held companies operating in industries that aren’t structurally built for being publicly listed. Public listing isn’t necessarily a precursor for large-scale growth. For instance, infrastructure businesses that generate value through long-term targets need not be under the constant glare of quarterly results that is a necessary concomitant of being a publicly-traded company.

Primarily, businesses that have an asset profile that is long-dated with lumpy payment schedules, will struggle in the public domain. Mind you; such companies deliver all the requirements that one expects from a business of investments, job creation, paying taxes and engaging in impactful CSR activities. DVRs have a significant role to play in providing such industries access to capital.

Also Read- Hawaii Islands’ Highest Peak, Mauna Kea, Best Place for World’s Largest Telescope

As India needs to both boost growth and create capital markets that generate value for all stakeholders, innovation such as DVRs is essential. As with all policies, effective implementation of DVR policy is as important as the content in the policy per se. DVRs have the potential to create Indian enterprises that have the capital structure stability to truly compete globally. (IANS)



K'taka Hijab Row Triggers Debate.

By M.K. Ashoka

The issue of wearing a hijab (head covering worn in public by Muslim women) to the colleges along with the uniform has sparked a debate in Karnataka over religious practices impacting the education system in the state. The matter has also snowballed into a controversy on whether the hijab could be considered as part of the uniform. The ruling BJP is deliberating on whether to take a call on allowing hijab as part of the uniform of college students. State Education Minister B.C. Nagesh, while opposing the wearing of hijab to classrooms, has said that a decision would be taken on the issue soon by the government.

The experts as well as students are divided over the issue. Those who are in favour state that the dress code in classrooms should not indicate faith or religion as it creates barriers between students as well as teachers. Those who support the wearing of hijab say that hijab should be treated as a scarf. Hijab is black in colour and it can't be a religious symbol as Islam is identified with the green colour. The hijab should be treated as a symbol of chastity, they maintain.

The denial of permission to six girls in the Government Girls' Pre University College in the communally sensitive district of Udupi in the state has created a controversy. Nagesh dubbed it as a political move and questioned whether centres of learning should become religious centres. Meanwhile, the girl students have decided to continue their protest until they are allowed to attend classes wearing hijab.

Keep Reading Show less

Police have come under sustained attack around the country. | Unsplash

An Indian-American police officer, who has been on the job for just over six months, is being hailed a hero for rushing to neutralize a gunman who shot a police officer and wounded another. Sumit Sulan, 27, shot the assailant who surprised the officers opening fire on them in his mother's flat on January 21 where police were called because of a domestic dispute. Jason Rivera, 22, was killed and Wilbert Mora, 27, was wounded, but Sulan who was in the police party advanced and shot the alleged gunman, Lashawn McNeil, 47, according to police.

Also Read : Police in Spain distribute masks to commuters

Keep Reading Show less

The most common allergen in India are milk, egg and peanuts.

By Dr Nidhi Gupta

Motherhood comes with its own mixed bag of emotions; we want to save our child from every little peril that comes their way, including allergies. The most common allergen in India are milk, egg and peanuts. According to the IAP survey, 11.4 per cent children under the age of 14 years suffer from some form of allergies and they usually peak around the month of May.

The symptoms of allergy range from runny nose, sneezing, coughing, rashes, watery and red eyes to swollen tongue and breathing difficulties. A child experiences serious discomfort and it leaves the parents hopeless at times. Allergies develop slowly over time; parents need to have patience and commitment towards managing them. However, there are certain ways in which we, as parents, can contribute in prevention and possible alleviation of the problems.

* Do Not Stress

Staying stress-free and calm is very important during this time. Creating panic will only add to the misery. Once we know about the symptoms, our mandate must be to keep a first-aid antiallergic kit at home. We can make this kit with the help of our paediatrician.

Keep reading... Show less