Friday, December 4, 2020
Home Life Style Health & Fitness India’s Move to Ban e-cigarettes Flawed, Say Cancer Experts

India’s Move to Ban e-cigarettes Flawed, Say Cancer Experts

Borland said that e-cigarettes are an “important tool” for smokers to reduce their risk and this opportunity to improve public health will be lost if India continues to bans e-cigarettes

Tobacco use, particularly smoking, exacts a heavy toll in India every week but the government move to ban e-cigarettes while allowing sale of normal cigarettes does not seem justified, cancer experts said.

Addressing a press meet organised by bcbpf-The Cancer Foundation, Riccardo Polosa of the Department of Clinical and Experimental Medicine at Italy’s University of Catania, Ron Borland, Professor of Psychology at the University of Melbourne, and Sameer Kaul, Senior Consultant, Surgical Oncology & Robotics at the Apollo Cancer Institute here, questioned the ban on electronic nicotine delivery systems (ENDS) in the country.

Claiming that the Indian Council of Medical Research white paper shows “a high probability of bias”, they asked why it recommended a complete ban on e-cigarettes for the “greater interest of protecting public health” but not on traditional cigarettes.

Policy-making should be based on scientifically sound evidence and where such evidence is in nascent stages, efforts must be focused on speeding up or encouraging research, they said. Kaul announced a nation-wide, cross sectional, randomized study on Indian subjects, led by bcbpf-The Cancer Foundation, of which he is the founder President.

Saying it was important to “document the well-known damaging effects of smoking against the risks and harm reduction potential of e-cigarettes”, he said that the ban of e-cigarettes that have “proven social, economic and health benefits over combustible cigarettes, is not justified”.

e-cigarette, cigarettes
Customers puff on e-cigarettes at the Henley Vaporium in New York City. VOA

“ENDS present an excellent opportunity for India to accelerate a decline in smoking rates and adult smokers who want to quit but may be unable to, have the right to be able to access harm reduction alternatives such as ENDS,” he added.

The three experts recently co-authored and published a scientific evidence based critical appraisal of the ICMR white paper, in the Indian Journal of Clinical Practice.

Polosa said that the ICMR paper “presented an uncritical evaluation of evidence gathered from poor quality studies”, and they sought to make “a detailed, critical appraisal of all existing evidence on ENDS” in a bid to “convince ICMR to reconsider their recommendation for a complete prohibition of the category”.

Also Read: Infosys, Microsoft to Offer New Solutions for Digital Shift: Report

He said many reputed scientific institutes now acknowledge that ENDS pose significantly less health risk compared to traditional cigarettes or bidis. As many as 69 countries, like the UK and Canada, have regulated ENDS while the UAE has reversed its ban.

Borland said that e-cigarettes are an “important tool” for smokers to reduce their risk and this opportunity to improve public health will be lost if India continues to bans e-cigarettes. (IANS)



Most Popular

India’s E-Commerce Industry Reported Nearly 56 Percent Growth This Festive Season

India's e-commerce industry reported nearly 56 percent growth in order volume this festive season amid the pandemic as compared to the same period last...

‘Operation Talwar’, A Story Of The Valour Of The Indian Navy

BY SHANTANOO MISHRA If the border of a country is secure, then both development and history can be created. All the three armies of India...

Indian American Teen Gitanjali Rao Is ‘Kid Of The Year’ By TIME Magazine

TIME magazine has put an Indian American teen "scientist and inventor" Gitanjali Rao on its first-ever 'Kid of the Year' cover, selected from a...

Christopher Nolan: Indian Films Are Wonderful And Are Kind Of Fundamental

Christopher Nolan feels Hindi films happen to retain the fundamental reasons due to which we enjoy cinema, and that Hollywood has lost some of...

Natural Antioxidants That Helps Body To Deal With Pollution

The air that we all are breathing has reached dangerous levels of pollution yet again. People with no known history of respiratory problems are...

A Focus On Academic Entrepreneurs In India

India is the third-largest tech start-up hub globally, yet academicians are still on the fringes when it comes to entrepreneurship in the country. The...

Indians Willing To Take Salary Cut To Work From Home

Amid the Covid-19 pandemic, at least 54 percent of working Indians said that they love working from home (WFH), of which 34 percent are...

Energy Efficiency Sets Slow Not Reaching Climate Goals

The already sluggish pace of global progress on energy efficiency is set to slow further this year due to the economic impacts of the...

Recent Comments