Wednesday September 26, 2018

Obamacare: Lessons Indian healthcare can imbibe


health-621353_640By Dr. J.K. Bhutani

The healthcare system of any country, be it US or India essentially has three key players, viz. Providers, Payers and the Public Health. The successive governments have had many successes inter playing these keys and such actions have led to many improvements in the US healthcare delivery systems. But much work still remains to be done. The private and public insurance reforms and other interventions apart, one in six Americans still does not have insurance cover and thus, cannot access the best health care.

The infant mortality, the life expectancy, other health parameters and quality of healthcare have improved over the years but the cost escalation has increased to disturbing levels too. The US health care costs are disturbingly high, so much so that the providers are sometimes labeled as ‘Working just for commerce and profits unlike the forefathers who worked for serving the humanity’.

From Harry Truman shortly after World War II, to Barack Obama now, many presidents have tried to reform the US healthcare system. The most laudable and controversial has been ‘The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act of 2010’ or ACA, which has attempted to recognize and support the key role of Public Health in the healthcare system. The US Supreme Court recently upheld the nationwide availability of tax subsidies for the implementation of President Barack Obama’s signature healthcare law… Obamacare (Affordable Care Act – 2010).

Of the four components of any health delivery system (Patients, providers, payers, and public health), The Affordable Care Act attempts for more funding and key role of Public Health. The ACA shall reduce ‘out of pocket’ expenses and bring all preventative care under insurance… subsides by the Federal Government. All developing economies including India, need to learn and strengthen the Public Health institutions from the greedy corporates and their ‘Target-business’ models of health delivery for hospitals and service providers.

Other issues which need attention in US and India are –

1. The American health system with a provision of ‘cutting edge technology’, ‘micro-specialization’ and the ‘best evidence-based practice state of the art medicine’, is the role model for the whole world. The costs are more essentially because of the excessive reliance on the investigative ‘work up’ for fear of litigation. The bulk of the common diseases which have self-limiting course are also worked up unnecessarily.

The primary care strengthening should address this and some strategy can be evolved and legislated to keep common day-to-diseases out of the ambit of litigation. This single step can reduce the cost of nearly 80 percent of the diseases which have an insignificant or self-limiting course.

2. The onus of responsibility exclusively on the Federal Government though sounds responsible but is more of a populist measure for winning the elections in democratic set ups. The onus of the physical and mental health of the family and children should be the responsibility of the parents and the role of the governments should be to improve the social component of health like providing good civil conditions and good environment including water, housing etc.

3. The Insurance concept makes us all reckless with our health and should not be owned completely by the governments and should be shared by the people especially for the Metabolic disorders and Lifestyle diseases like Obesity, Hypertension, Diabetes, Trauma, Alcoholism, Drug Abuse, etc. for which the person himself should pay and Federal Government should only have affirmative role in such diseases. These should be out of ambit of Medicare or Medicaid and insurance subsidies….!


Dr J.K.Bhutani MD is a protagonist of preventive and promotive health care based on austere biology and facilitating self-healing powers of human organism.
You can follow him at

Click here for reuse options!
Copyright 2015 NewsGram

Next Story

Paralyzed Patients Start Walking Following A New Treatment

the researchers say this is not a cure for paralysis, and caution that it may not work on every patient. They say more study is needed.

A wheelchair sits in the viewing area at a golf course, June 19, 2017. Medical researchers are working to stimulate the spinal cord to allow paralyzed patients to stand and walk.. VOA

U.S. researchers are reporting progress in helping those paralyzed by spinal cord injuries to stand, and even to take steps.

Two teams of medical researchers working separately say an electrical implant that stimulates the spinal cord allowed three paralyzed patients to stand and move forward while they held on to a walker or were supported from the back.

One patient was able to walk the length of a football field.

“Recovery can happen if you have the right circumstances,” University of Louisville professor Susan Harkema said, adding that the spinal cord can “relearn to do things.”

Bionic exoskeleton helps wheelchair users stand and walk. Flickr

Experts say that a damaged spinal cord leaves the brain unable to send messages to the nerves that activate the muscles.

The researchers believe those nerves are still alive, but are asleep.

Stimulating them with electricity, along with intense rehabilitation, can wake up those sleeping nerves and enable them to receive commands again.

Other earlier treatments using electricity allowed patients to stand and move their toes, but not walk.

Experts say that a damaged spinal cord leaves the brain unable to send messages to the nerves that activate the muscles.

But the researchers say this is not a cure for paralysis, and caution that it may not work on every patient. They say more study is needed.

Also Read: HP Launches Game Changing 3D Printing Technology

Reports on the new therapy appear in the New England Journal of Medicine and the journal Nature Medicine. (VOA)