Friday, October 23, 2020
Home Education Supreme Court: NRI Quota Not Compulsory In Medical Colleges

Supreme Court: NRI Quota Not Compulsory In Medical Colleges

Seats shall be offered to the NRI applicants solely on the basis of merit

The Supreme Court on Friday held that the NRI quota in private medical colleges is not sacrosanct, but the institutions intending to do away with it must give reasonable notice to the aspirants.

A bench comprising Justices L. Nageswara Rao and S. Ravindra Bhatt said: “It is evident that the NRI quota is neither sacrosanct, not inviolable in terms of existence in any given year, or its extent. However, if a medical college or institution or, for that matter, the state regulating authority, such as the board in the present case, decide to do away with it, reasonable notice of such a decision should be given to enable those aspiring to such seats to choose elsewhere, having regard to the prevailing conditions.”

The top court noted that as a part of the private colleges’ autonomous decision making, they could set apart some percentage of seats for admission to students of their choice. “The NRI candidates could not assert a right to be admitted,” it said.

The NEET PG Medical and Dental Admission/Counselling Board issued a notice doing away with the NRI quota, and as a result, the candidates, who have applied for NRI seats, will be considered based on eligibility criteria in the absence of the quota.

Two candidates had challenged this decision in the Rajasthan High Court, where a single judge bench, citing the verdict of the top court’s seven-judge bench, said the candidates had already qualified the NEET-PG examination and qualifying it, and after having approached the colleges for NRI seats, can’t be deprived of admission in the NRI quota.

Supreme Court decision
Candidates under the quota cannot assert their right to be admitted, says court in a judgement. Pixabay

The single judge also directed their immediate admission to the colleges.

However, this decision was reversed by the high court’s division bench, which held that private colleges can do away with the NRI quota, and instead fill the management quota by considering NRI students.

The top court noted that as per its verdict, four crucial elements in the NRI quota are: “One, the discretion of the management (whether to have the quota or not); two, the limit (15 percent); three, that seats should be available for genuine and bona fide NRI students, and lastly that the quota was to be filled based on merit.”

The top court observed that the respondent management possessed the discretion to indicate whether, and to what extent, NRI reservations could be provided.

ALSO READ: Bihar Girls Set Up ‘Sanitary Pads Bank’ with Rs.1 Per Day Contribution

“It was, and remains within the discretionary authority of the management of private medical colleges, within their internal policy-making domain. The impugned judgment, in this court’s opinion, is correct, in that it held that the single judge could not have directed admission of the candidates before him,” the bench said.

The top court suggested that to do justice to all the parties, a special counseling session should be carried out by the board, and seats shall be offered to the NRI applicants solely on the basis of merit. (IANS)



Most Popular

Down Syndrome May Increase COVID Death Risk

Researchers have found that down syndrome is associated with a 10-fold increased risk for COVID-19-related death. Down syndrome (sometimes called Down's syndrome) is a condition...

Miss India 2020 Pageant Held Virtually Due to Pandemic

In the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic, Miss India 2020 pageant will be held virtually the Miss India Organisation has announced. A nationwide audition to...

6 Designers Came Together to Help Craft Clusters Impacted by Pandemic

Six fashion designers came together to support marginalized craft clusters and those heavily impacted by the pandemic by generating livelihood opportunities for the artisans....

India Rapidly Expanding High Power Supercomputers

India is fast expanding its supercomputer facilities and developing the capacity to manufacture its own supercomputers in the country, the Ministry of Science and...

Cholesterol Medications May Lower Cancer-Related Deaths in Women

Among women with breast cancer, colorectal cancer, or melanoma, those who are taking cholesterol-lowering medications are less likely to die from cancer, researchers said. The...

Immediate Biomedical Waste Management Halts COVID Spread: UNIDO

The United Nations Industrial Development Organisation (UNIDO) on Tuesday stressed the need to halt the spread of COVID-19 through all possible infection channels, including...

1.16L Infant Deaths in 2019 Due to Air Pollution in India

The first-ever comprehensive analysis of air pollution's global impact on newborns finds that outdoor and household particulate matter pollution contributed to the deaths of...

Literature and Movies: Filmmaker Suman Mukhopadhyay

While reading 'Chuti Nakoch', a story by writer Ashapurna Devi, he suddenly felt grabbed by the jugular. It was tough to ignore the visual...

Recent Comments