Saturday April 21, 2018
Home Indian Diaspora History of Ko...

History of Kohinoor as explained by William Dalrymple

There is no doubt, the Antique rock has a long and complicating history and it is difficult to resolve to which country it belongs to

3
//
878
Kohinoor Diamond Source: Wikimedia commons
Republish
Reprint

By Akanksha Sharma

For the past few days, the precious Kohinoor Diamond has been hitting the news again. The Indian govt. informed the court that, the eminent colorless diamond was ‘gifted’ and not forcefully taken away by the British. This revelation by the govt.  has acted as an incentive towards the ongoing debate, whether the famous stone should be returned to India or not?

The Historian/Author William Dalrymple who is working on his upcoming non-fiction history book Kohinoor said, “While I was working on my previous book on Shah Shujah Durrani’s (ruler of the Durrani empire in present day Afghanistan from 1803-1809) life, I got some Persian manuscripts from Kabul. I came across this chapter between the time Nadir Shah (Shah of Persia) left India and when the diamond came back to India with Maharaja Ranjit Singh. So this was information on the Kohinoor that people did not know about, through Afghan Sources”.

 

Kohinoor, Koh-i-noor, Kohinoor diamond, William Dalrymple, Kohinoor William Dalrymple, Kohinoor Dalrymple, Kohinoor history, Ranjit Singh, Shah Shujah Durrani, Kohinoor Ranjit Singh, Kohinoor Shah Shujah Durrani, Kohinoor Nader Shah
Shah Shujah Durrani (left) and Maharaja Ranjit Singh (right) Source: Wikimedia Commons

While doing his research on Kohinoor to understand its complex history, he found manuscripts from Afghanistan and further explained “The Indian case rests on the claim that the British took away the diamond by force. I think there is no doubt about that. It is complete nonsense that, it was gifted by Maharaja Ranjit Singh of the Sikhs. Maharaja Ranjit Singh kept it with him his whole life. It was during the regency of his son Duleep Singh, that the diamond was taken away. There is not much to dispute about that. It was part of the peace treaty of the British and was handed over in the process of the defeat of the Sikhs as one of the spoils going to the victor.”

Related articleIndia says British Queen should keep its Koh-i-Noor

“However, what complicates this is that the diamond did not come peacefully to Ranjit Singh either. Indians claim that Shah Shujah gave the diamond to Maharaja Ranjit Singh. But Shah Shujah’s autobiography clearly mentions that his son was tortured by Maharaja Ranjit Singh before he took away the diamond. So if the Indian case rests on the claim that the British took it by force, so did the Indians.”

By the mid-19th century when it reached the hands of British, it has already been possessed by many leaders and kings, all of which were not ‘Indian’. “By the time the diamond passed from the Afghans to Maharaja Ranjit Singh, the diamond had been with the Afghans of the Durrani Empire for two to three generations. It kept getting transferred peaceably through each generation and finally came into the possession of Shah Shujah. Shah Shujah in his autobiography mentions that his son was tortured and that he was starved for days by Ranjit Singh in order to get the diamond,” explained Dalrymple.

According to the Dalrymple’s perspective, besides India there are other countries also who can lay claims on Diamond like Afghanistan and Iran. During the time when it passed through the hands of many rulers, the national boundaries were not well defined thus, it is difficult to decide to which country it belongs to. Pakistan and parts of Afghanistan were parts of India. When Nadir Shah attacked India and took the possession of Kohinoor, Kabul and Kandahar were being ruled from Delhi. Right now, there are three lawsuits in Pakistan, seeking claims on Kohinoor.

 

Nader Shah during the sacking of Delhi in the aftermath of his victory at the Battle of Karnal, 1739

It is true that the colourless diamond originated in Golconda Mines of India, later Nadir shah passed it to Persians long before British looted Sikhs. “The great looting of the Mughals was not by the British. By the times the British are powerful, the Mughals have already lost everything to the Persians. While the British did loot India, particularly Bengal, the big looting was done by Nadir Shah,” he further said.

“It in only because of the way the British wrote history that people have remembered the Kohinoor while everything else is forgotten. Other objects of loot like the Darya Noor (which is a sister diamond of Kohinoor) and parts of the Peacock throne are in Iran and nobody speaks about it.”

There is no doubt, the Antique rock has a long and complicating history and it is difficult to resolve to which country it belongs to. And Historian Dalrymple explained the reason how it has long lived throughout the history and still remembered.

“It in only because of the way the British wrote history that people have remembered the Kohinoor while everything else is forgotten. Other objects of loot like the Darya Noor (which is a sister diamond of Kohinoor) and parts of the Peacock throne are in Iran and nobody speaks about it.”

Speaking of the claims made by Indians that it should be brought back to India, he further added “It will be a matter of national pride, but it will open up a large number of grievances. Should the Dravidians now put a lawsuit against the Aryans, or should the Shudras start suing the Brahmans? The Kohinoor is a symbol of how complex and intractable history is. History is full of horror stories.”

“My personal view of all this is that history is far too complicated and entangled to think that there is anything to be gained by asking for retribution. Where does one stop? Should Britain seek retribution from Norway and Sweden for the Viking raids? Equally, should the Sri Lankan government send a bill to India for the Chola raids of Anuradhapura? This is not a healthy way of conducting international relations. One should be educated in history in the least biased way possible.” he said.

Akanksha is an intern at NewsGram and pursuing Journalism and Mass Communication in New Delhi. Twitter:@Akanksha4117

Click here for reuse options!
Copyright 2016 NewsGram

  • Jasjeet Singh

    William Dalrymple needs to fix his story. Maharaja Ranjit Singh had a VAKIL (attorney) Mr Sohan Lal Suri who used to write daily diary of his Darbar namely Umdat-Ut-tawarikh. The real story as per Umdat-Ut-tawarikh is as follows:

    Shah Shuja-ul-Mulk was imprisoned by Atta Mohammad Khan, Governor of Kashmir under Maharaja’s Kingdom. He was he who tortured Shah and his family. Shah’s wife Wafa Begum contacted Maharajah Ranjit Singh and plead for his release and she promised to offer Koh-i-noor in return. Maharaja after his findings ordered on 6th day of Zil Hajj Sambat 1869 (1812AD) to free Shah and he was brought to Lahore and offered Haveli known as Mubarak and Rs 1000 cash for an entertainment. Shah family lived there with comfort.

    On the day of Holi festival of same year, Deewan Bhawani Dass, Munshi Karam Chand and Bhai Ram Singh met Shah’s agents Habibulla Khan and Haifz-Ruh-Ullah to close the business of Koh-i-noor. After long discussions the price of diamond was set as Rs 3 lakh advance and Jagir (territory) yielding income of Rs 50,000 per annum. Shah had to handover Koh-i-noor in 50 days.

    On 29th Jamadi-ul-Awwal (May 30, 1813)- Fiqir Aziz-ud-din, Bhai Gurbaksh Singh, Jamadar Khushal Singh went to Shah and told him expiry of 50 days. The Shah said, “ let Maharaja come and have it”. Maharaja with certain Chieftains and 1000 foot soldiers entered Mubarek Haveli, located in the Mochi Darwaz. Shah with folded hands offered Diamond and had an agreement written down purporting to non-interference with him and his descendants in future in regards to Jagir. Maharaja was very happy at the sight and presented Shah 20 rolls of Shawls, brocade, Gulabadn and the like. Shah also presented two Doshalas and One turban to Maharaja. The wisest Judges declared the weight of gem to be equal to 42 Mashas.

    The Shah had very cordial relationship with Maharajah. He was deposed by his brother in 1809 and he lived in Punjab till 1837. He regained his Kingdom with the help Sikhs especially Gen Hari Singh Nalwa in 1839. Hari Singh Nalwa was killed in this expedition.

    The koh-i-noor was purchased by Maharajah and it was not snatched, stolen, surrendered or gifted by Shah.

  • Pritam Go Green

    Its not what we Indians need to worry out. Britian won’t give it to us that easy.

    • Pashchiema Bhatia

      In fact, its next to impossible.. Its way difficult to prove that it belongs to India as it has a complicated history

  • Jasjeet Singh

    William Dalrymple needs to fix his story. Maharaja Ranjit Singh had a VAKIL (attorney) Mr Sohan Lal Suri who used to write daily diary of his Darbar namely Umdat-Ut-tawarikh. The real story as per Umdat-Ut-tawarikh is as follows:

    Shah Shuja-ul-Mulk was imprisoned by Atta Mohammad Khan, Governor of Kashmir under Maharaja’s Kingdom. He was he who tortured Shah and his family. Shah’s wife Wafa Begum contacted Maharajah Ranjit Singh and plead for his release and she promised to offer Koh-i-noor in return. Maharaja after his findings ordered on 6th day of Zil Hajj Sambat 1869 (1812AD) to free Shah and he was brought to Lahore and offered Haveli known as Mubarak and Rs 1000 cash for an entertainment. Shah family lived there with comfort.

    On the day of Holi festival of same year, Deewan Bhawani Dass, Munshi Karam Chand and Bhai Ram Singh met Shah’s agents Habibulla Khan and Haifz-Ruh-Ullah to close the business of Koh-i-noor. After long discussions the price of diamond was set as Rs 3 lakh advance and Jagir (territory) yielding income of Rs 50,000 per annum. Shah had to handover Koh-i-noor in 50 days.

    On 29th Jamadi-ul-Awwal (May 30, 1813)- Fiqir Aziz-ud-din, Bhai Gurbaksh Singh, Jamadar Khushal Singh went to Shah and told him expiry of 50 days. The Shah said, “ let Maharaja come and have it”. Maharaja with certain Chieftains and 1000 foot soldiers entered Mubarek Haveli, located in the Mochi Darwaz. Shah with folded hands offered Diamond and had an agreement written down purporting to non-interference with him and his descendants in future in regards to Jagir. Maharaja was very happy at the sight and presented Shah 20 rolls of Shawls, brocade, Gulabadn and the like. Shah also presented two Doshalas and One turban to Maharaja. The wisest Judges declared the weight of gem to be equal to 42 Mashas.

    The Shah had very cordial relationship with Maharajah. He was deposed by his brother in 1809 and he lived in Punjab till 1837. He regained his Kingdom with the help Sikhs especially Gen Hari Singh Nalwa in 1839. Hari Singh Nalwa was killed in this expedition.

    The koh-i-noor was purchased by Maharajah and it was not snatched, stolen, surrendered or gifted by Shah.

  • Pritam Go Green

    Its not what we Indians need to worry out. Britian won’t give it to us that easy.

    • Pashchiema Bhatia

      In fact, its next to impossible.. Its way difficult to prove that it belongs to India as it has a complicated history

Next Story

Shoot The Rapist At The Sight

 And which type is contributing more dangerously to the society can easily be measured with our simple plus and minus equation

0
//
19
This glaring aberration in the world of media is visible as clearly as stars in the darkness of the night.
India is plagued with a disease called Rape. Wikimedia Commons

Salil Gewali

  • India is plagued with a disease called Rape
  • There are no rigorous punishments for rape
  • Rapists openly commit crimes without anny fear

Why the clamour only for the rigorous punishment for rape and other sadistic crimes which have their roots in the mental-degeneration? Apart from the toughest punishment to the perpetrators, let’s go deeper to analyze what could be the possible  “causes”  that push men to commit rape. Why so much mental degeneration that certain individuals can stoop to the gutter being to their status, their position and social values? Well, how to address those issues is certainly a challenge. And that “challenge” certainly calls for a serious brain-storming and a serious self-assessment vise-a vise the environment in which we all are living.

Ranaghat Nun Rape Case
Rape culture in India garnered more spotlight following the Nirbhaya-gang rape, after which the issue has continue to remain a burning topic in the country. Pixabay

True, in the physical world we are highly convinced brag about that healthy environment is a must for our healthy living. Even kids know these days that we can’t breathe well if our surroundings are filled with high levels of  “toxicity”. We have well studied through our academic textbooks that people invite the environmental disaster if they keep on allowing excessive emission of CO2, CO, methane and other dangerous gases into the atmosphere. We have fully acknowledged that each tall and black chimney of the industries and the nozzles of the motor vehicles are here only to mar the beauty of this planet? What kind of damages the toxic gases are doing to our ecosystem are not at all tough job to analyze with modern appliances. Again, a lot amount of books have been published to create the awareness, to inform us about the scientifically tested measures to resolve the environmental concerns.

However, do we have the same amount of literature that pinpoint the “causes” which contribute to turning “males into perverts”? Who else is emitting the “toxic substances” that overpower the inborn sensitivity of the deviant? What are the properties of toxic filth that is polluting the mind-scape of the society? Now we have Donald Trump, the president of the USA, whom many prefer call him a pervert. At this rate, the number perverts are increasing and they have become dangerously ubiquitous. And, all those perverts have brought nightmares to the ill-fated females. We often stage candle march in protest against the rape, but remain blind to the glaring “causes”. Should we still fiddle about and be appreciative of the society that shameless covers itself with the vulgarity — the “toxicity” that might numb the sanity of males? Watch out, dear friends, those perverts have begun to see even “baby girls” as objects of lust!

Please note:  what our sages said:  “What you see that you think, what you think that you do and what you do that become !!!!”

Also Read: Eat Grapes To Ward Off Depression

Again, I would like to draw another similarity with what prompt big people to “rape”/violate the harmony of the Mother Earth. The case is very regularly brought out by the conscious citizens across the country. A senior journalist Patricia Mukhim of Meghalaya has pointedly driven home recently how the “greed for money” has corrupted many leaders who are trying hard to justify the senseless exploitation of the “body” of Mother Earth. Many big shots of big companies struggle to convince the politicians to tweak the laws to grant the permission to perpetually “rape” the country.

In my mind, both are infected with common syndromes! While the one type is interested in the body of the females, the other type has a fetish for the rocky body of the “Mother Earth”. And which type is contributing more dangerously to the society can easily be measured with our simple plus and minus equation.

The rape victims are not getting the justice they deserve.
The rape victims are not getting the justice they deserve.

Let’s assess the issues from another angle, given the advancement of medical science. Till some years back malaria, dengue, cholera, HIV, smallpox were life-taking diseases. But the medical science has pretty successfully eradicated or contained them all. The scientists have correctly identified the causes of those dangerous diseases and recommended the remedial measures. No doubt, that is a very productive achievement. However, why have the modern studies practically failed to “identify the causes”  of the pandemic rise of the horrendous instances of rapes and criminality associated with them? Is it not a strong slap in the face of the modern civilization considering we have not yet spelt out the causes and the characteristic symptoms the  “toxic emitters” who turn decent males into sadists? How long will we endure the depravity which has already strangulated the decency of the society? Should we still wait to work out the tough laws? Should we still hitch to explore for the “causes” and remedial measures? I guess the time is ripe that each morally conscious individual be allowed a shotgun to shoot the “perversion and depravity” of any kind at sight!

Salil Gewali is a well-known writer and author of ‘Great minds on India’. Twitter: @SGewali.