Friday, October 30, 2020
Home Lead Story Critics Slam Facebook With Their Own 'Real Oversight Board'

Critics Slam Facebook With Their Own ‘Real Oversight Board’

A New Oversight Model for Facebook Content

While an independent Facebook oversight board with 20 external members of the society (including one from India), formed in May this year to offer a new model of content moderation for Facebook and Instagram, is yet to begin functioning, a new alternative “the Real Facebook Oversight Board” has come into existence.

Formed last week by critics of the social network, the organizers slammed Facebook for a weak and inconsistent approach to threats or implications of violence.

They said Facebook has not done enough to counter premature claims of a Republican victory this November presidential election, reports Forbes.

“Our group has come together for one purpose: We demand comprehensive action to ensure that Facebook cannot be weaponized to undermine the vote and with it American democracy,” said Shoshana Zuboff, professor emerita at Harvard Business School and author of the book titled “The Age of Surveillance Capitalism”.

The original Facebook oversight board has Sudhir Krishnaswamy, Vice-Chancellor of the National Law School of India University in Bengaluru, and the only member on the board from India.

Currently, content moderation is done within the company. Besides using technology to bar harmful content from appearing on the sites, they also have a human moderation system.

Organizers slammed Facebook for a weak and inconsistent approach to threats or implications of violence. Unsplash

The Facebook oversight board will give users a chance to appeal against any wrongful removal of their content. The decisions of the board will be binding on Facebook and Instagram.

“There are three possible channels through which cases can come to the Oversight Board. The Facebook content moderation team may itself refer a case to the board or a user may bring up a case and potentially even the Oversight Board itself might feel that a particular case should come to it,” Krishnaswamy told IANS in a recent interview.

Meanwhile, the members of the alternative Facebook oversight board warned that future regulation and a possible forced break-up could come for Facebook.

“We’re not waiting for another election to go wrong. We believe accountability in real-time is vital,” they said.

In November 2018, Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg announced a new ‘independent’ body to provide outside oversight, and in May this year, the first 20 members of its new Oversight Board were announced.

“But it’s still not operational and even if it was, it only has limited powers to rule on whether the content that was taken down should go back up. And once a case has been referred to it, this self-styled ‘Supreme Court’ can take up to 90 days to reach a verdict. This doesn’t even begin to scratch the surface of the many urgent risks the platform poses to the upcoming election,” said the new alternative board.

The Facebook oversight board will give users a chance to appeal against any wrongful removal of their content. Pixabay

According to Krishnaswamy, the Facebook board will also review whether Facebook and Instagram will implement its decisions.

“Both Facebook and Instagram as well as their CEO have given a clear unequivocal undertaking that the decisions of the board will be implemented. We are confident that our decisions will be implemented,” he said.

Also Read: Here Are Some Useful Tips for Acing Your Fashion Game This Autumn

However, Krishnaswamy, who is also Co-Founder of the Center for Law and Policy Research which works to advance constitutional values for everyone, including the LGBTQ+ and transgender persons in India, added that whether in the physical world or the Internet universe, there will always be some “compliance problem”. (IANS)



Most Popular

Localized Content Driving New Customers in Amazon Prime Video

Riding on localized content being churned out in countries like India, the number of Prime members who stream Prime Video grew by more than...

Cheerful People Likely to Experience Less Memory Decline

People who feel enthusiastic and cheerful -- what psychologists call "positive affect" -- are less likely to experience memory decline as they age, say...

BCG Vaccine Can Help Managing COVID in Elderly: ICMR

The Bacille Calmette-Guerin or BCG vaccine, originally made against tuberculosis, may help in the management of COVID-19, especially in the elderly, says a study...

5 Simple Things to Improve Your Life and Your Bank Account

We’re always searching for ways to boost our wealth, improve our health, and increase our standing among our peers, but often, the best ways...

Uttar Pradesh To Get State Organ Tissue Transplant Organization

The Yogi Adityanath government in Uttar Pradesh has decided to set up the State Organ Tissue Transplant Organization (SOTTO), a state-level body that will...

Is Intelligence Necessary When It Comes to Making Money- Greatway Financial Weighs In

By Jamie Cartwright Intelligence might help you score well on a math test or enable success in academia, but it’s not necessarily a determining factor...

Are Instant Personal Loans In India Easily Available

By Shubhi Gupta All of us go through a bad phase in life when we are in need of instant money but are short of...

Teenager Suffers Rare Nerve Disorder Post Covid19 Treatment

A 14-year-old boy who had developed Miller Fischer syndrome, a variant of rare Guillian-Barre Syndrome -- where the immune system attacks the nerves, due...

Recent Comments