Annabelle Doll Missing After Paranormal Investigator’s Mysterious Death, Tour to Continue Despite Panic

Key points:

Paranormal investigator Dan Rivera, 54, was found dead in his hotel room in Gettysburg, Pennsylvania, on July 13, shortly after leading a sold-out ghost tour titled Devils on the Run at the haunted Soldiers National Orphanage. The event prominently featured the infamous Annabelle doll—allegedly cursed and the inspiration behind The Conjuring film series. When authorities entered the room, not only was Rivera found alone and unresponsive, but the Annabelle doll had mysteriously vanished. There was no forced entry or any suspicious signs at the scene, and the Adams County Coroner confirmed the cause of death is still pending as autopsy results are awaited.

The disappearance of the doll triggered a wave of panic online. Conspiracy theorists were quick to link Rivera’s sudden death to Annabelle’s ominous past, despite law enforcement asserting that “nothing unusual or suspicious” was observed in the room. Days later, the doll was quietly recovered, but its brief vanishing act has only fuelled public fears and speculation.

Rivera, a respected member of the New England Society for Psychic Research (NESPR), was traveling with the doll as part of their nationwide paranormal tour. Attendees and fans pointed out the disturbing pattern of events—Rivera dying in one of America's most haunted towns, the doll vanishing, and a history of other eerie incidents linked to the relic—as “too many red flags to ignore.” Some attendees have since withdrawn from future tour dates, unwilling to tempt fate any further.

The Dark History of the Annabelle Doll

The Annabelle doll has long been at the center of terrifying legends and paranormal claims dating back to the 1970s. Originally given to a nursing student named Donna in 1968, the doll allegedly exhibited strange behavior—moving around the apartment on its own, and even leaving handwritten notes on parchment paper that no one in the house owned. A psychic medium later told the roommates that the doll was inhabited by the spirit of a young girl named Annabelle. Their attempts to appease the spirit, however, were met with increased hostility and apparent violent intent.

Paranormal investigators Ed and Lorraine Warren eventually took the doll, declaring it demonically possessed. According to their accounts, the doll once caused the brakes to fail on their car as they transported it, and was linked to the death of a priest who had mocked it. It was later secured in a glass case in the Warrens’ Occult Museum in Connecticut for decades.

Despite widespread skepticism from academics and science writers—who dismiss the stories as myth and folklore—the doll’s reputation has only grown, especially through its depiction in The Conjuring Universe, where it appears as a cracked porcelain figure with a sinister grin.

See Also:

Aftermath and the Show’s Future

Despite Rivera’s mysterious death and the brief disappearance of the doll, the NESPR has confirmed that the “Devils on the Run” tour will continue in his memory. Organizers said, “We believe with all our hearts that Dan would have wanted the work to continue—bringing people together, sharing knowledge, and honoring the memory of Ed and Lorraine Warren. We will carry his spirit in everything we do.”

Annabelle’s next scheduled appearances include the Maine Paranormal & Horror Convention in Augusta from September 6–7, followed by tour stops in Illinois and Kentucky. However, calls to retire the doll have grown louder online. Many argue that Annabelle should never have left the Warrens’ glass case, and fear that continuing to display her could invite further tragedy.

Whether cursed or not, Annabelle’s reputation as one of the most haunted objects in paranormal lore continues to send chills—and now, she has claimed yet another name in her infamous legacy. [Rh/Eth/VP]