Monday March 30, 2020

Reservation system an ‘amoeboid monster’, says Gujarat HC Judge


Ahmedabad: Gujarat High Court’s Justice JB Pardiwala, on Tuesday, spoke against the need of the reservation system in India even after more than six decades of independence.

“The parody of the situation is that India must be the only country wherein some of the citizens crave to be called backward,” said the judge to TOI, lamenting the fact that certain communities in the country still demand the benefits accompanying the quota system.

According to the judge, the two forces of reservation and corruption have worked together in holding back the nation’s progress and causing its downfall.

“It is very shameful for any citizen of this country to ask for reservation after 65 years of independence. When our constitution was framed, it was understood that the reservation would remain for a period of 10 years, but unfortunately, it has continued ever after 65 years of independence,” he said.

Justice Pardiwala, who accepted sedition charges against Hardik Patel, the Patidar quota stir leader, while dropping the charges of waging war against the state, further said, “The biggest threat today for this country is corruption.”

“The countrymen should rise and fight against corruption at all levels rather than shedding blood and indulging in violence for the reservation. The reservation has only played the role of an amoeboid monster sowing seeds of discord amongst the people. The importance of merit, in any society, cannot be understated,” he added.

Next Story

Reservation issue from the eyes of a young college student


By Aakash Sinha

Reservation! As the word is uttered we see mixed reactions from the people of India. Why not? Eligible ones have a big smile on their face, for others it is just an Indian political tradition that must go on. Not a single aspect is left without the controversial word “Caste Reservation”. Education, scholarship, jobs, promotions- it’s everywhere. We say, India is fast growing, developing nation, then why we are still unable to phase it out? Why no political involvement is seen in handling it? Well, it’s interesting to know the answers.

Walking into history of time somewhere around 1901, first time reservation was introduced in Maharashtra to provide free education in the province of Kolhapur. After independence in 1982, Supreme Court of India announced quotas for SC (Schedule Caste) and ST (Schedule Tribe) in the field of education and jobs at the public sector, initially for 5 years. Transforming the motto of reservation, political parties made it a way to attract voters of this category and it kept on increasing until it reached 50% (After the constraint given by Supreme Court Of India). India was divided into General, OBC (Other Backward Caste), SC and ST in 1990 after Mandal Commission.

How does it affect the society? To remove the caste inequality, seats were reserved in educational institutions. Starting from the basic education in schools to the professional education in colleges, it’s a part of our life. But here the question arises, why is it so? Let us take the case of two students, one from general category and another is a SC, ST or OBC. While admitting to the school, the other student got the benefit of reservation. Now both students studied together with the same teacher in the same environment. So now I think that they are equal with the same knowledge. Alas! The story doesn’t end here. The other student is eligible for more favours. During the admissions to government colleges (IITs, AIIMS, IIMs etc.) the reserved category student will get admission but the more talented guy will be sitting outside and watching the game. What type of equality is it? Wait! Wait! It doesn’t stops here. It is further continued during jobs (different cut-off’s for different category). Now I think it should stop. My God! It also engulfed promotions after entering into govt. jobs (already benefited by reservation). A shocking fact: only 0.7% of scholarships or student aid in India is based on merit, the rest are reservation based. This way it is harming a part of society while blessing the other.

Why it still exists? Thinking upon this much debatable topic, I think all credit goes to the political class. Politicians will never want to be trapped in the controversy related to it. Why? The answer is “Power”. India has political parties of several hues and colors . If one party tries to sort out the situation other will oppose it to make use of the mistake done by the latter. Thus, the situation remains the same.

At present much of India is still fragmented by caste. But two decades of economic liberalization, government policies and increased awareness among people themselves have kick-started the process of change.

It is unlikely that there will be a complete transformation soon, but some say that for a country shackled with centuries of discrimination even a start is good news.

You can only bring the change!

Aakash is pursuing B.E , Electrical and Electronics Engineering from Sir M. Visvesvaraya Institute of Technology, Bangalore. Twitter:@aakashsinha1994

2 responses to “Reservation issue from the eyes of a young college student”

  1. i think u forget that they get reservation only in entrance exam after admission they have to pass it and pass marks are same for everyone and For sc st in medical entrance they have to score certain 40% to get eligible for counselling and to get seat in mbbs they have to score at least 50% where a gen cat have to score 55% to get mbbs so there is difference but those difference is not so much as it make to look like I don’t know about other entrance exam so i cant tell you about that..I m sc but sitll i dont get in mbbs last doesnt mean that if u are reserved category u will get admission there is also lot of compitition it is not so easy as it look like from outside