Friday, April 23, 2021
Home Lead Story Today's Democracy Is Not What US Founding Fathers Envisaged

Today’s Democracy Is Not What US Founding Fathers Envisaged

Democracy in action today might not be exactly what the founders envisioned, money and power do continue to play a vital role in U.S. politics

The founders expected the common people, the poor and uneducated, to participate indirectly, through their local government, at town halls and meetings, and through protest actions like boycotts. Some of the founders were particularly concerned about populism and mob rule. “These were the kinds [of people] that thought that democracy was a dirty word. Even John Adams said stuff like that. He didn’t want poor people to vote, he didn’t want women to vote,” Wehrman says.

Follow NewsGram on Facebook to stay updated.

Bruce Kuklick, a professor of American history emeritus at the University of Pennsylvania, says the framers of the Constitution had a very different idea of democracy than Americans do today. “The founders didn’t want this sort of democracy at all. The Constitution is written so that citizenship rights are very, very limited,” he says. “They worried about democracy … It was a bad form of government because once you let everybody participate, then you’re likely to elect a demagogue. You’re likely to have people come to power who appeal to the frenzy of the masses. That idea is long gone.”

Wehrman points out that the framers of the Constitution saw to it that only one part of one branch of the federal government, the House of Representatives, is popularly elected by the people. The Electoral College chooses the president, the commander in chief selects the Supreme Court justices and, originally, senators were selected by state legislatures.

founding fathers
George Washington, president of the 1787 Constitutional Convention and America’s first U.S. president, was born into a landowning family and married a wealthy widow. VOA

“It’s another attempt to kind of whittle away at the direct participation of a large group of people in the political process,” Kuklick says. “So there are all these other constraints that they write into the Constitution to shore up what they think might be a leaky vessel, where too many ignorant, poor people get the right to vote.”

It was only after the 1913 ratification of the 17th Amendment to the Constitution that U.S. senators were elected by direct popular vote. “Clearly, the Constitution was written and enacted to pull back some of the actions that were taken by state legislatures. People like James Madison and Alexander Hamilton thought that the state legislatures and voters in most states had gone too far, that too many people were participating in politics, too many people were voting,” says Wehrman.

For example, New Jersey gave the right to vote to residents who could reach a certain property ownership threshold. This included women and African Americans, who were able to vote from 1776 until 1807 when the state restricted voting rights to white men.

“They (the founders) thought that there were too many voices in the state legislatures, that states were becoming too radical, that they were beholden to the interests of the common man when they needed to be more reserved and more accommodating to wealthy, educated business-interest types,” Wehrman says.

founding fathers
James Madison, called the “Father of the Constitution” by his contemporaries, was born into wealth and went on to become the fourth U.S. president. VOA

So what would people like Alexander Hamilton, John Adams, and the other framers of the Constitution think about America today? “I think they would all be sort of delighted that the general framework that they created is still in action,” Wehrman says.

And they might even be open to change. After all, they did write in a process for changing or amending the Constitution. They even availed themselves of that process with the ratification in 1804 of the 12th Amendment, which established separate Electoral College votes for president and vice president. The tweak kept political adversaries from opposing parties from serving in the same administration as president and vice president. Even so, Kuklick says, the Founding Fathers would be considered reactionaries by today’s standards.

ALSO READ: Consumers in US Spend Average USD $138 on iPhone Apps in 2020: Report

“[They] didn’t want what came to be,” Kuklick says. “And one of the amazing transformations of the United States in the 19th century is that we go from having this very, very limited view of participation by the people in the government, to the one that people just now completely accept as being the democratic way.”

Although democracy in action today might not be exactly what the founders envisioned, money and power do continue to play a vital role in U.S. politics. And, given that the vast majority of American presidents and founding fathers have been independently wealthy, the founders’ aim of reserving a prominent place in government for the rich has essentially been realized. (VOA/SP)



Most Popular

High Risk Of Death For Covid Survivors Due To Serious Illness

Covid-19 survivors -- including those not sick enough to be hospitalised -- have an increased risk of death in the six months following diagnosis...

Covid Times: Mumbai Police Rocks With A Dollop Of Wit And Grit

Displaying a tough countenance and wielding the baton, the Mumbai Police has also shown its little-known humor quotient as it tightens belts to enforce...

Inspiring Sustainable Stays In India

Earth Day 2021 was celebrated yesterday and instead of reminiscing about the trips you have taken in the past twelve months, for many, it...

A List Of Readable Titles To Choose From While You Stay At Home

From navigating career misadventures in the corporate world to building a personal brand or navigating one's own thoughts and feelings on the prolonged 'new...

Depressive Symptoms Identified In Pregnant, Postpartum Women: Study

Pregnant and postpartum women reported high levels of depression, anxiety, loneliness, and post-traumatic stress during the Covid-19 pandemic, according to a worldwide survey. Such high...

Art Of Cutting Paper

He calls the art of cutting paper meditative. He smiles that whenever he starts doing that, it is tough to take him away. For Bangalore-based...

Mass Gatherings Led To A Rapid Surge In Covid19 Cases

By Salil Gewali Even a child knows that we should not play with fire. But amidst the raging heat of the pandemic, the government certainly...

Buying Organic Will Help Preserve The Planet

You may feel overwhelmed by the outpouring of slogans and labels on eco-friendly living without really understanding the need to go organic. Here's a...

Recent Comments